Transcript
Professor Samuele Cortese Hi, my name is Samuele Cortese. I am an NIHR Research Professor and a Professor of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry at the University of Southampton in the UK and, also, Professor of Child Neuropsychiatry at the University of Bari in Italy, and at the University of New York in the United States.
The presentation today will focus on the “Comorbidity Between ADHD and Medical or Physical Conditions,” which I think is very exciting topic and relatively novel. I think many of us who are familiar with ADHD know very well the so-called neuropsychiatric, or psychiatric comorbidities, of ADHD, so we know, of course, that ADHD tend to be comorbid with oppositional defiant disorder, anxiety disorder, mood disorders, and so on and so forth. But there’s been less attention over the years on the comorbidities with physical conditions, and I think there is an emerging literature on this topic, which is also interesting for the implications for the clinical practise. So, in this presentation, I will try to provide an overview of this literature.
Alright, so, before moving actually to the presentation itself, this is the disclosure of possible conflict of interest for me, and let’s move then to the presentation, as such. So, as I mentioned, I think there’s been really an increasing awareness on the importance of somatic or physical conditions associated with psychiatric disorders. And this is built on the notion that many conditions, which classically have been thought to be as a nervous system disorder, so disorders of the brain, actually include, also, alterations in other physiological systems, in other parts of the body. And it will be really unwise not to consider these comorbidities, because, of course, we are supposed to treat the – our patients in a holistic way, rather than in a very fragmented way.
So, based on this understanding, in the past 15 years, or so, there’s been an increasing number of studies looking at the associations, and their implications, between ADHD and alterations in other physiological systems. And it would be quite challenging for me to summarise all these studies in this presentation, but fortunately, we had – we have just published what I think is an important piece of evidence in this field, which is what we call an “umbrella review.” So, umbrella review is a systematic review of meta-analysis, or systematic reviews in the field, so it’s really the highest level of evidence synthesis that we can think of. And in this umbrella review, we were interested in knowing the associations between ADHD and comorbid health conditions, in general.
So, if you look at the paper, you will find these graphic apps that – which hopefully is helpful to summarise the key findings. So, as you can see here, we found evidence for significant associations between ADHD and a number of conditions in the body that you see reported in this figure. One of the important aspects of umbrella reviews is that also gives the certainty of the evidence so it can grade the certainty of the evidence around the findings. So, based on this, we actually concluded that there are a group of conditions for which we know there is high-certainty evidence that they are associated with ADHD, in a very strong way statistically, but there are, also, other conditions which are associated with ADHD with lower level of certainty, but still statistically significant. And, finally, some other conditions that – for which there is low-certainty evidence because of methodological problems in the included studies. And you will see all these conditions here in this slide, so I will not read, of course, for you, but you have a very comprehensive list.
And you can see that, interestingly, many of these conditions are related to alterations of the immune system, so immunological alterations may play a role in the comorbidities. We know, also, that there are also genetic factors that may explain the association, but, also, lifestyle factors that explain the association between ADHD and other conditions. Right, so, this was an overview of the evidence, and we know then that there is a significant association, but the point for Clinicians I think is, okay, so what are the implications of these association in our clinical practice? Well, I think the obvious implication is that we need to be mindful of this, we don’t need – we don’t have to overlook these associations, and the management of comorbid condition is important. I will focus now, in particular, as an example, on the management of the comorbidity between ADHD and obesity, because it does have important implications.
So, let me show you the result of a study which was conducted several years ago, and this was a study conducted in a bariatric clinic for individuals with severe levels of obesity, who were refractory to a standard treatment for obesity. Now, until this study, nobody had checked how many of these had ADHD. When the authors, the Researchers in this study, checked the presence of ADHD with standardised tools, so in a very rigorous way, they found that out of 242 individuals with a severe obesity in this clinic, 32% had ADHD, a formal diagnosis of ADHD. And when they treated them with a pharmacological treatment, they found that at the endpoint, after 14 months, those treated with a pharmacological treatment for ADHD had lost 10% of their weight. Those who didn’t have ADHD, and hence they were not treated pharmacologically for ADHD, unfortunately, they were not able to lose weight, so they still presented their refractory obesity.
Now we may think, of course, one of the effects, the side effects of stimulants, pharmacological treatment of ADHD, is weight loss. But this was not an explanation here, because these findings were reported after 14 months of treatment, and we know that usually the weight loss is more pronounced during the first weeks or months of treatment. So, rather than thinking that this was a side effect of the medication, the most plausible explanation is that the management of ADHD in those individuals who had obesity and also ADHD allowed a better control of executive dysfunction. And this, in turn, allowed them to be able to better follow the treatment, to adhere to the diet, to have a healthier lifestyle, and hence to lose weight.
So, the key message I think from this study is that, actually, it is important to be aware of this comorbidity, and the treatment of ADHD may have a positive impact, not only on ADHD itself, but, also, on the comorbid obesity, which, as you can imagine, is very important from a public health point of view. And, finally, I wanted, also, to highlight that this is not just the case for pharmacological treatment, it can occur also with non-pharmacological treatment. So, this was a study where the authors tested the effect of executive function training and, once again, improving executive functions, via this training, had a positive effect after 25-session, in terms of weight loss in these were children with obesity. So you see there is clearly a difference in body mass index.
So, once again, I think that the overall message is – from this presentation is, really, we should be aware of these important links between ADHD and physical condition, and the treatment of ADHD may have beneficial effects that go beyond ADHD itself. Thank you for your attention.