Transcript
Dr Lucia Magis-Weinberg Well, hello, my name is Dr Lucia Magis-Weinberg, and today I’m going to talk to you about social media and mental health in adolescence. I always like to start by saying that “adolescence is a window of opportunity.” Adolescence is a time of remarkable opportunity and growth. It is now defined “from ten to 25,” and it’s the stage in our lives in which we discover, we learn from, and adapt to the world around us. It is a key period of our lives, where we forge our sense of who we are and who we aspire to be, where we learn to make decisions, manage our emotions, create deeper connections with peers and others in our communities. Where we also build resilience, as the pandemic has so starkly shown us, where we develop our interests, passions, and meaningful goals that will shape our adult lives. And it’s a time of unique brain development, of accelerated remodelling of our brains, and these brains are well suited to the many tasks that I described, but too often, the systems around us are not.
So, this unfortunately means that adolescence, although it’s a time of remarkable opportunity, it’s also a time of vulnerability, in terms of mental health. And here I show a list of common mental health disorders, and on the Y axis, we see ages from five to 50, and in that orange box around there, you can see how many of the mental health disorders that I – that a person can manifest through their lives will usually first manifest in the age of adolescence. So, I’m thinking about social anxiety disorder, eating disorder, mood disorders, many of them first show when we are in adolescence.
And there is many reasons why this is the case. This vulnerability to mental health is associated with the enormous bodily changes that we’re going through, as I said, our brains are drastically being remodelled. There’s also a lot of psychological transitions that young people go through, right? So, in terms of developing their autonomy, their many identities, it is a time where we have more sophisticated thinking, more cognitive capacities. It’s a time of profound social transition. So, in early adolescence, many of us will go from elementary school to secondary school, and that’s very challenging, and it’s a key period where we reorient from our families to our peers.
There is important developmental milestones, right? So, it’s a time of many firsts, it’s a time where friendships profoundly transform, a time where we break-up with our first romantic relationships, where we get in fights with our friends, and that is very, very challenging for young people. And it’s a time where we experience graduations, our first parties, our first trips with friends, right? And all of these things have always happened, even before digital devices and social media, but since the last perhaps 15, ten years, a lot of these big milestones of adolescence are also happening in online environments, right? So, it is not surprising that we tend to associate social media and the digital world with a lot of these concerns that we have for mental health. And one of my main messages today is that social media, although we love to put it – to single it as a scapegoat, it is definitely not the full story, right?
I do want to be very balanced in my message today. I do believe, and the data shows, that the digital world has profound opportunities for young people, as well as risks. I want to start with the opportunities today. So, we know – Dr Livingstone talks about the “ladder of children’s online participation,” and we know that for most young people in the world, at the bottom of a – of the ladder, a lot of young people are using their devices for entertainment. Recent data has shown how for young people streaming, especially YouTube is the platform they wouldn’t live without, and it’s great that young people can turn to the digital world for entertainment.
Of course, digital media is key today for socialisation and communication. It helps us foster our in-person relationships. We also now have online only friends, right? Young people have friends that they have never met in person, they might never meet them in person, but they’re still very real relationships for them, and young people turn to the online world for profound social support and connection with others. As the pandemic shown – has shown us very starkly, the digital world has enormous opportunity in terms of education and information, right? We use digital devices when we’re at school. In the pandemic, we were also learning remotely, connecting to schools, to our Teachers, using these devices, and young people are consuming lots of information, and they’re consuming a lot of information about their own mental health. When they have issues, when they have questions, they’re going to the online world.
And lastly, as young people get more skills and more comfortable with the online world, we would like for all young people to climb through all the steps in the ladder of online participation, and really get to the last step of this ladder, which is really exerting your community and your citizenship. I think of Greta Thunberg, this adolescent who has shown you how – shown us how you can actually change the world for the better when you use social media to organise young people around the world in the fight against global warming, for example. Or I think of young people in the United States who have mobilised for gun control and gun reform. Young people have a lot of power when they know and they can use these tools for change, right?
On the other hand, of course, I do not want to minimise the risks that very much exist. Again, Sonia Livingstone and colleagues talk about the “4Cs of Risk,” I think this framework is very useful for us to understand them. So, on the one hand, there is the risk of content, right? Young people are consuming violent content, content that has – that is sexual, that is age inappropriate, they’re consuming mis and disinformation, they’re consuming all this marketing, right? There’s another risk in terms of content with ill-intended adults, right? Where the digital world can open the door to harassment, to surveillance, to glo – grooming, exploitation or radicalisation, for example. There’s also a risk for conduct problems with peers, right? So, there’s bullying and digital drama that exists in our online relationships, there’s sexual harassment and pressures from our peers, and digital world also gives young people access to harmful user communities, right?
And, lastly, the four – the fourth C of risk is that risk of contract, and the commercial risks that young people and adults experience when they’re online. There’s risk for fraud, for security, for trafficking. We are contending with this persuasive, very engaging design, data profiling, these algorithms who are deciding what we want to consume, right? So, I do want to paint a very nuanced picture of both the opportunities and the risks. And something that’s very important for me to highlight is that these opportunities and risks do not exist on a vacuum, right? The digital world is both reflecting the real, the physical, world, and it’s also impacting the physical world. So, it is important that we consider the digital world in concert with the physical world and the micro, meso, exo and microsystems that are surrounding young people.
And the last thing that I really want to highlight is this idea of potential, right? Even though today, youth are very familiar with technology, they won’t magically extract all the positives, all the opportunities, without scaffolding and support, and at the same time, we can also prevent online harms from happening, right? It is important that we support youth, that we regulate online environments to promote the positives and reduce the negatives.