Transcript
Dr Alan Meehan When thinking about a young person’s likelihood of experiencing ACEs, Researchers usually think about two things. So, they usually think about risk factors, so these are things that increase the possibility of experiencing ACEs or their harmful effects down the line, but they also think about protective factors. So, these are things that might decrease the likelihood of experiencing ACEs or their potential harmful consequences on our health.
Now, because ACEs involve a range of different types of experiences, there are many risk and protective factors that might apply to different ACEs or that may be more influential for some types of adversity compared to others. However, there are many factors that have been shown to be related to multiple ACEs and by raising awareness about these risk and protective factors, we might provide important targets for strategies and initiatives that seek to prevent ACEs or reduce their prevalence across the whole population. So, what kinds of family or home circumstances might contribute to a higher risk of ACEs or potentially place young people at higher risk of negative outcomes where they’ve been exposed to adversity? Well, a big area of risk involves families where significant socioeconomic difficulties might be at play. For example, low or single-income families, families where the adults have low levels of educational attainment, so, for example, maybe they didn’t finish school, and families where caregivers are experiencing high levels of economic stress.
Certain caregiver behaviours that might increase risk of ACEs, as well, in the children, include things like use of corporal punishment, inconsistent discipline or also, poor monitoring or supervision from caregivers. Finally, families that are socially isolated and less connected to other people, like extended family members, friends and neighbours, may also be at high risk of ACEs. And levels of risks may also be heightened if they live in a community where there are high rates of violence, there’s crime, unemployment or unstable housing, or residents or neighbours are less involved on connected with their local community.
Now, we know ACEs themselves act as an important risk factor for a wide variety of long-term problems, but we also know that not all children who experience adversity will go on to show those unfavourable or adverse outcomes. And in fact, many young people appear to be what we call resilient, in that they go on to live relatively healthy lives, despite the adversity they’ve experienced in the past. So, therefore, it’s also important to think about the protective factors that might prevent or reduce the risk of unfavourable outcomes following ACE exposure. And typically, when we think about or organise these different types of protective or resilience factors, we do it across three different levels, based on whether they’re related to the individual themselves, their immediate family, or the community or wider society.
So, just to start with the individual, when we think about personal characteristics that might be protective against developing health problems for those with ACEs, it includes things like high levels of self-esteem, self-efficacy and self-regulation, use of adaptive coping strategies, high levels of optimism, a strong sense of identity and self-worth and also, certain personality characteristics, for example, high levels of extraversion and low levels of neuroticism. At the family level, then, potential protective factors that have been looked at in research include things like a stable, warm and supportive relationship between the caregiver and child, high levels of parental monitoring and supervision and just general, kind of, involvement and engagement in the child’s daily life. And also, social support from other family members, both within and outside the, kind of, immediate household.
Finally, in terms of the wider community, factors that appear to be related to resilience include things like social support from non-family members, a sense of what’s known as social cohesion in the neighbourhood or the community, and also, available – availability of support resources and services in the community. So, availability of, kind of, childcare, medical and Police services. Other things, also, beyond the, kind of, immediate household, include things like a positive attitude towards school and support from peers and friends and participation in things like sports and other extracurricular activities.
So, overall, for those who’ve already experienced ACEs during childhood, raising awareness about these resilience factors that I’ve just mentioned could be particularly important in supporting the development of interventions that could reduce or mitigate the most harmful consequences of ACEs, whether that’s within clinical or mental health services or other frontline settings.