Transcript
Rosie McGuire PTSD stands for post-traumatic stress disorder and this mental health difficulty develops in some people who have experienced a shocking, scary or dangerous event. It’s natural to feel afraid during and after a traumatic situation. Fear is a part of the body’s fight or flight response, which is built into our brains to help us avoid or respond to potential danger. People may experience a range of reactions after trauma and most people recover from initial symptoms over time. Those who continue to experience problems may be diagnosed with PTSD.
Anyone can develop PTSD at any age. Mostly, people associate this mental health difficulty with people who’ve fought in war, but this can happen to people who’ve experienced or witnessed all sorts of trauma, such as physical or sexual assault, abuse, an accident or a disaster. Lots of things can be considered traumatic and people define trauma in different ways. There are two main diagnostic manuals that are used by professionals to help them categorise and diagnose mental health difficulties. These are the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, known as the DSM, and the International Classification of Diseases, known as the ICD. These manuals define trauma slightly differently. The DSM specifically suggests that trauma involves “exposure to death, threatened death, actual or threatened serious injury or actual or threatened sexual violence.” The ICD simply states that the event must have been “extremely threatening or horrific” to be considered a trauma.
There are events that might not meet these particular criteria, but which may still be traumatic for the individual and may lead to symptoms of PTSD or to other significant mental health difficulties. Not everyone with PTSD has been through a traumatic event first-hand. You can also develop PTSD if you’ve seen it happen to someone else, or sometimes learning that a family or friend has experienced trauma can cause PTSD. It’s now also recognised that people can develop PTSD from repeated or extreme exposure to details of a traumatic event experienced by people that they don’t know, for example, people that work within Emergency Services.
Symptoms of PTSD usually begin within three months of the traumatic event, but they sometimes can emerge later. As mentioned in my initial description of trauma and PTSD, there are two main diagnostic manuals that are used by professionals to help them categorise and diagnose mental health difficulties. These are the DSM and the ICD. As well as being slightly different in how they describe trauma, they’re also slightly different in how they describe PTSD symptoms. So, to meet diagnostic criteria for PTSD, a person must “have symptoms for at least several weeks” according to the ICD and “for over a month,” according to the DSM. The DSM also suggests that “symptoms must not be caused by a medication, substance use or another illness.” Both manuals state that “Symptoms must be severe enough to interfere with aspects of daily life and functioning,” such as with relationships or work and school.
After a traumatic event, it’s natural to have some symptoms initially. For example, people may have recurring distressing thoughts, memories or nightmares about the trauma. However, if difficulties relating to the trauma continues a month after the trauma happened, then a diagnosis of PTSD may be considered. A mental health professional who has experience helping people with PTSD, such as a Psychiatrist or Psychologist, can determine whether symptoms meet the criteria for PTSD. There are three groups of symptoms that are common in both diagnostic manuals, so these are often considered the core symptoms of PTSD. These are re-experiencing symptoms, avoidance symptoms, and arousal and reactivity symptoms.
The first group of symptoms, re-experiencing, include experiencing flashbacks, which is where a memory of the trauma comes to mind, but it feels like you’re living the traumatic event all over again, and it can include physical symptoms, such as increased heartrate or sweating. Another re-experiencing symptom is having recurring memories or dreams related to the event. Thoughts and feelings can trigger these symptoms, as well as words, objects or situations that are reminders of the traumatic event. So, it makes sense that people with PTSD then might want to avoid those reminders, and this is related to the second group of symptoms, called avoidance symptoms. These include staying away from places, events or objects that are reminders of the traumatic event and avoiding thoughts or feelings related to the traumatic event and therefore, perhaps avoiding talking about it. Avoidance symptoms can cause people to change their routines. For example, they might avoid driving or riding in a car after a serious car accident.
The third group of symptoms relates to arousal and reactivity symptoms, which are often constant and can, therefore, have the biggest impact on daily life. These include being easily startled, feeling tense or on edge, or feeling irritable, having angry or aggressive outbursts, having difficulty concentrating or difficulty sleeping, and engaging in risky behaviours.
The DSM-5, which is the latest version of that particular diagnostic manual, also includes a fourth group of symptoms, called cognition and mood, and these include having trouble remembering key features of the traumatic event, having negative thoughts about yourself or the world, having exaggerated feelings of blame directed towards yourself or other people, ongoing negative emotions, such as fear, anger, guilt or shame, losing interest in enjoyable activities and feeling socially isolated and finding it difficult to feel happy or satisfied.
Including this final group of symptoms does increase the overlap with other mental health difficulties, but it allows for a wider range of symptom profiles to be classified as PTSD and also, acknowledges that some of these broader difficulties may actually be trauma related. Whilst I’ve described the diagnostic criteria here, I think it’s important to acknowledge that people find different kinds of meaning in diagnosis. For some people, it helps them explain or make sense of the difficult experiences that they’re having and the impact that that’s having on their lives. But for other people, they may feel that it’s stigmatising, reductive, meaningless, or result in them feeling like they’re being treated as a set of symptoms rather than a person. And this is important to consider when discussing diagnostic labels like PTSD, especially with the individuals that are experiencing these difficulties.
The most recent version of the International Classification of Diseases, the ICD-11, has included a separate diagnosis called ‘complex PTSD’. Complex PTSD consists of the same core symptoms of ICD-11 PTSD, which are re-experiencing, avoidance, and arousal and reactivity, but it also has three additional groups of symptoms, which are sometimes referred to as ‘disturbances in self-organisation’.
These are problems with emotion regulation, such as marked irritability or anger or feeling emotionally numb, poor self-esteem, which can be accompanied by feelings of worthlessness, shame, guilt or failure, particularly related to the traumatic event, and difficulties in sustaining relationships and in feeling close to other people. Typically, people experiencing these additional complex trauma symptoms will have experienced multiple long-lasting, repeated or continuous trauma.
Research has indicated that the diagnosis of complex PTSD can also apply to children and young people, as well as adults. One study of young people taking part in a treatment trial for PTSD found that 40% of them had high levels of these additional symptoms required for complex PTSD. It’s typical for children and adolescents to have a range of reactions after experiencing or witnessing a traumatic event. Many of these reactions are normal and will lessen with time. However, if they persist for more than a month after the trauma, it’s possible that some of these behaviours could be considered symptoms of PTSD. Many of these symptoms are the same as the core symptoms of PTSD in adults, which are re-experiencing, avoidance, and arousal and reactivity. These are sometimes just a bit different in young people, depending on their age and development. It’s particularly helpful for parents and carers to know about the behavioural symptoms and then, they can look out for those.
So, regardless of age, children and adolescents may report having physical problems, such as stomach aches or headaches, have nightmares or other sleep problems, including refusing to go to bed, have trouble concentrating, lose interest in things they used to enjoy, have feelings of guilt for not preventing injuries or deaths and have thoughts about revenge. Younger children, typically aged five and below, may have additional symptoms related to their development. So, they may also cling to their caregivers or cry and be more tearful. They may have tantrums or be irritable and disruptive. They may suddenly return to behaviours such as bedwetting and thumb sucking. They may show increased fearfulness, for example, fear of the dark or monsters or being on their own. And they might incorporate aspects of the traumatic event into imaginary play.
Older children, typically aged six and over, and adolescents, might have more problems in school. They might become withdrawn or socially isolated from family and friends. They might avoid reminders of the event. They might have difficulty remembering the event or remember it in the wrong order. They may use drugs, alcohol or tobacco. They may be disruptive, disrespectful or destructive, and teenagers especially may be more impulsive and aggressive, and they may be angry or resentful. If these symptoms last for more than a month after the trauma, the family could reach out to a healthcare provider to investigate whether the child may be displaying symptoms of PTSD.
According to the National Center for PTSD in the US, about six out of every 100 people will experience PTSD at some point in their lives. Women are more likely to develop PTSD than men, and certain aspects of the traumatic event and some biological factors, such as genes, may make some people more likely to develop PTSD than others. The cause of PTSD can vary. Some people recover within six months, while others have symptoms that last for a year or even longer. People with PTSD often have co-occurring difficulties, such as depression, substance use or anxiety disorders.
We have various theories to help us understand how PTSD may develop. Probably the most well-known, Ehlers and Clark’s Cognitive [audio cuts out - 13: 44] TSD [audio cuts out 46] them
identifies “alterations in memory, cognitions and behaviour” as critical factors which serve to prolong the experience of PTSD. This model suggests that a strong feeling of current threat, despite the knowledge that the trauma they experience is now in the past, is the key to the development and maintenance of PTSD. This results from three overlapping processes: negative appraisals related to the trauma, the sensory nature of the trauma memory, and maladaptive cognitive and behavioural coping strategies.
For people with PTSD, the meaning they make about the trauma, also called ‘trauma-related appraisals’, are often very negative. These appraisals could relate to themselves, such as, “I’m responsible for what happened to me,” or “I’m permanently damaged because of what happened,” or these appraisals could relate to people or the world around them. For example, “The world is a dangerous place.” This leads to poor self-esteem and a feeling of current threat. In addition, for those with PTSD, their trauma memories have particular characteristics, such as being very vivid and sensory, fragmented, involuntarily recalled and creating a strong physical or emotional reaction. These characteristics make the memory feel like it’s actually happening in the present moment, rather than being recalled as a memory.
It’s thought that trauma memories have these characteristics when they’ve not been properly consolidated into the long-term memory, along with this contextual narrative that helps it integrate with other autobiographical memories. This context is what helps us to consciously remember events and be able to tell the story about what happened. It’s thought this process doesn’t happen for people with PTSD because they’re avoiding memories of their trauma. Instead, these trauma memories are recalled unconsciously or involuntarily when a sensory trigger, such as a sound or smell, reminds them of their traumatic experience. This leads to re-experiencing symptoms and also, ignites that feeling of current threat.
The negative appraisals and intrusive memories are maintained by maladaptive cognitive and behavioural coping strategies that aim to reduce current threat, for example, avoidance of thinking about the trauma or any associated triggers. This is well intended and is used to prevent the stress in the short-term, but in the longer-term, this prevents cognitive change, for example, in how they feel about themselves and about the threat around them. And it also prevents change in the trauma memory, therefore, prevents recovery from these distressing symptoms of PTSD. Therapeutic techniques which address these mechanisms form the basis for effective treatments for PTSD.
For some people, PTSD symptoms go away on their own a few months after the trauma, but for others they can persist without psychological intervention. If symptoms of PTSD do persist and are causing significant impairment, individuals can work with a mental health professional to help address and reduce these symptoms. Treatment can involve therapy, medication or a combination of both. A mental health professional can help people find the best treatment plan for their symptoms and needs.
Some people with PTSD, such as those in abusive relationships, may be living through ongoing trauma. In these cases, treatment is usually most effective when it addresses both the traumatic situation, to ensure that they’re in a place of safety, as well as the symptoms of PTSD. People who experience traumatic events or who have symptoms of PTSD may also experience panic disorder, depression, substance use or suicidal thoughts. Treatment for these difficulties can also help with recovery after trauma. Research also shows that support from family and friends can be an important part of post-trauma recovery.
The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence put together guidance, which is known as the NICE Guidelines, and these are based on research evidence to suggest what the most effective treatments are for reducing symptoms. These guidelines suggest that trauma-focused cognitive behavioural therapies are the most effective at reducing PTSD symptoms in children and in adults. One type of trauma-focused cognitive behavioural therapy is called cognitive therapy for PTSD, which is derived from Ehlers and Clark’s Cognitive Model of PTSD. Cognitive therapy for PTSD has three key aims that address each of the processes described in the Cognitive Model for PTSD. So, firstly, to elaborate and update the trauma memory in order to reduce the re-experiencing symptoms. Then to modify negative appraisals and to change strategies that maintain the patient’s sense of threat and simultaneously, help them to reclaim activities in their life that promote a sense of worth and meaning.
So, different stages of cognitive therapy for PTSD can include developing specific and measurable goals for therapy. Developing a formulation which helps Therapists and patients to understand key symptoms and how these may be maintained by maladaptive coping mechanisms. Psychoeducation, which is where parents – patients learn about what PTSD is. Encouraging patients to reclaim their life, developing emotional regulation skills, encouraging patients to create a trauma narrative, meaning they’re exposed to trauma memories and can consolidate and update these. Developing grounding techniques that engage the senses, so that the patient can feel more engaged in the present moment rather than the trauma memory. Changing probla – problematic appraisals of the traumas and things that have followed those. Reducing unhelpful avoidance and safety behaviour, perhaps by visiting the location where the trauma happened. Training patients to work out what triggers they’re re-experiencing, and this is sometimes called ‘stimulus discrimination’. Summarising their learning and creating plans to prevent relapse, and sometimes it can be really helpful to engage the support system in therapy sessions, particularly for children, so that they understand PTSD and how to best support the patient with their recovery.
Sometimes it can seem daunting for someone with PTSD to tackle their avoidant coping and address their trauma memories. So, it’s important for mental health professionals to explain how thinking or talking about the trauma might help to reduce symptoms. This can enable people to make well informed decisions about whether to consent to, and engage with, interventions that focus on the trauma. An active engagement is necessary for processing to take place.
Some professionals choose to use metaphors to explain what happens in this type of therapy and a common one used is the wardrobe metaphor. This suggests that you can imagine your memories as items of clothing in your wardrobe. Usually, memories are neatly organised, so we know where they are and can take them out when we want them and put them back in their right place. But trauma memories are not neatly organised in the wardrobe. They’ve been thrown in quickly and have created a mess that’s going to be difficult to tidy up, so we avoid it. But this means that the clothes keep randomly falling out of the wardrobe because it’s overflowing and it’s difficult to close the door.
Therapy like cognitive therapy for PTSD, which is a type of trauma-focused CBT, it’s like the Therapist is coming along to help you tidy up your wardrobe of memories. They help you go through your memories like clothes and talk about them so that you have a clear idea of what happened, and then you can fold them up and put them away neatly so that you know where to find them in the future.