Transcript
Dr Amina Al-Yassin There are many different types of anxiety disorders which can affect children and young people, and it can sometimes be a little bit difficult to tell the difference between them. But as a parent, a Teacher, a Youth Worker, or anyone working with children, the most important thing is that you can identify when a child may be suffering from an anxiety disorder, and that you can help them get the support they need. That is much more important than working out exactly what type of anxiety it is, which the Doctor or mental health professional will be able to diagnose.
Amongst children, the most common types of anxiety disorder are separation anxiety, social anxiety, and generalised anxiety disorder, and in older young people, such as teenagers and adolescents, panic disorder is also quite common. The average age for developing an anxiety disorder in children and young people is 11 years old. The most common type of anxiety disorder in younger children, children below the age of 12, is separation anxiety. This is when a child is very worried when they are separated from their parents or their carer. It’s very common in young children. It usually develops at around six or seven months of age, and it can make settling into school or into any activity where the parent or carer will not be available much more difficult. Some young people have a more general school-based anxiety, where the concern is more about school itself, rather than the separation from the parent or carer. They may be anxious as a result of homework and schoolwork, or friendships or bullying, or they may be anxious because they’ve moved from one class to the other, or one school to the other.
Children do not always talk about their feelings and their worries, and sometimes school-based anxiety can show itself up in physical symptoms, like headaches or tummy aches, especially in the mornings, and especially on school days. Some children and young people have social anxiety, and this is when going out in public, seeing friends, taking part in activities and social activities with many other people can cause lots of fear or worry. This is not the same as shyness. Shyness is common, many people are very shy, but this is when the shyness is so severe that it can really affect their ability to go out and to engage and to do the normal things that people would usually like to do, like seeing friends, speaking on the phone, or mixing with others. Social anxiety is more common in young people who have been through puberty.
Another type of anxiety disorder are the phobias. A phobia is a specific worry about a very specific thing. Many children are afraid of dogs or monsters or spiders, and this is a normal part of growing up. However, again, if this fear is becoming so severe that it’s affecting their ability to get on with their normal day-to-day life, that’s when it would be considered to be a phobia.
Anxiety is not always specific to a particular thing. Generalised anxiety disorder is when someone can feel quite worried and they can’t quite pin down what the reason is. They may be worried about lots of different things, rather than one specific event, and they may, sort of, feel anxious or worried all the time, they may not even remember the last time they felt relaxed. This is when we would call this generalised anxiety disorder.
There are many other types of anxiety disorders too, such as post-traumatic stress disorder, which happens when a child or young person has experienced a life threatening, or an event that was perceived to be life threatening, and obsessive compulsive disorder. However, these anxiety disorders are more common in adults rather than children, so they won’t be our focus today. We all worry from time-to-time. All of us experience anxiety and anxiety is a very normal part of being a human, and in many cases, it can be very helpful. It can help us to – it can help warn us about danger and it can help us to avoid situations that may be unsafe for us. However, how do we know when a worry or a fear that a child has is more than just normal anxiety and is becoming an anxiety disorder, something that may need more help and support?
I like to remember this by the words TRAM, T-R-A-M. T is for transient, is this something – is this anxiety, this worry or this fear, is it something that has come and that is getting better? In which case, it’s less of a worry than if it’s been there for a long time and it’s persisted. The R stands for reactive, is this anxiety or worry happening as a result of a very specific event? So, for example, moving from one school to the other, or moving home, or parental breakup. All of this would be expected to cause anxiety in a child for a period of time. This is a reactive phenomenon and that’s also less worrying.
Is this appropriate? That A stands for appropriate, is this anxiety appropriate for their age and their development? So, a two-year-old who is very worried about leaving their mother, or going into nursery, that’s, you know, that’s a normal developmental stage, and something that wouldn’t be very worrying. However, if we found the same behaviour in someone who was 12 or 13, then it would definitely be worth looking into it a bit further.
And, finally, the M is for manageable. Is this anxiety – you know, they feel it, they experience it, but they’re able to carry on with their normal life. They’re able to go to school, they’re able to see their friends, or is it really getting in the way and becoming not very manageable? That’s when we would worry about it more. So, TRAM, T for transient, R for reactive, A for appropriate, and M for manageable. So, for example, if you were to go into a high school just before the exam period, most of the children, if not all of them, would be feeling pretty anxious. However, most of them would still be able to come into school, they would be able to complete their exam, and they would probably perform at the level that was expected, or predicted, by their Teachers. So, in that case, that’s normal anxiety and nothing to worry about.
However, if there was a young person who was so anxious that they were unable to come to school, or they were unable to sit their exams, or they were sitting their exams and they were so anxious that their performance was so much less than what would be expected by their Teachers, that’s when we would start to wonder whether this was more than normal anxiety. So, when should you get professional help for a child if you’re concerned about their anxiety?
Number one If you feel that it’s not getting better, it’s getting worse, you have tried a few tactics, you’ve tried a few things to help them yourself, and it’s not helped. Number two If you think it’s really starting to affect their schooling, their relationships, their performance at school or their attendance at school, or you think it’s really slowing down their development. Number three If the anxiety is happening very frequently and lasting for quite a while.
Number four If you feel that it’s really starting to affect the activities and the friendships that they usually enjoy. So, for example, they’re becoming really withdrawn, they’re going to great lengths to avoid any situation that make – may make them feel anxious, and that means that they’re maybe not doing the normal activities, clubs, or seeing the friends that they usually see. And, finally, if it’s starting to affect their sleep or their eating.
So, we all worry from time-to-time. Anxiety can be very normal, but we definitely need to be on the lookout for what we call the “red flags,” the signs that mean that a child or young person may need some more help. Anxiety at different ages Does the age of a child affect whether or not they experience an anxiety disorder? The simple answer is yes. So, in the UK, anxiety disorders are estimated to affect approximately five to 19% of all children and adolescents, but only two to 5% of children younger than 12, so, in general, anxiety disorders are more common in older children. And there are some important differences when it comes to age and, in fact, when thinking about anxiety disorders, it’s very important to understand a child’s age and their developmental stage.
So, for example, in separation anxiety, from the age of about six months to three years, it’s very, very common for a young child to have separation anxiety. In fact, a child who does not show any, sort of, reaction to being separated from their carer would be a cause for concern. And so, in this age group, it’s very normal for children to become quite clingy, to cry, to be distressed, if separated from their parent or carer, and it’s a normal developmental stage and something that should probably get better by the age of two to three. If this was to persist for much longer, or if it was to really start to affect their ability to attend or engage with nursery or school, then that’s when we would start wondering whether it was separation anxiety disorder, and separation anxiety is the most common anxiety disorder in children younger than 12.
If we now look at a slightly older age group, the preschool children, so children aged about three to five. In this age group, it’s very common to have specific fears or phobias, and common fears in this age group are things like monsters, spiders, strangers, and the dark, and usually these fears slowly start to get better on their own. And usually the child may need comforting or reassurance, but it will not really get in the way of their day-to-day functioning and their day-to-day activities.
However, if these phobias are persisting, they’ve been there for a long time, if it means that the child’s becoming withdrawn or anxious, and if it means that the child is going to great lengths to avoid any situation which may make them feel anxious, that’s when we start to wonder if this is a phobia and something that may need professional help. And, finally, and again, in the older age group, if we are now looking at adolescents, teenagers, children who are post-puberty, in this age group, panic disorder is more common, as is social anxiety disorder. And perhaps this is as a result of all the body changes that they go through at this time, increasing self-consciousness and the increasing importance and pressure of peer relationships. So, anxiety can be affected by age, both the type of anxiety that different age groups experience is different, as well as the prevalence, or how common anxiety is, in every age group is different.
There has been some research into the differences between anxiety and mental health disorders in males and females. A large Danish study looked at the prevalence of all mental health disorders and neurodevelopmental disorders, including autism and ADHD, between males and females. And they found that if we count them all up, then, overall, males have more mental health and neurodevelopmental disorders than females. However, interestingly, if we look just at anxiety, and especially if we look at that adolescent age group, then anxiety is more common in females than males, and that this difference emerges really early, so that even if you were to look at six-year-old children, anxiety is almost twice as likely in girls than in boys. Scientists have been asking what the reason is for this difference, and it may well be that there are different genetic and biological factors that play a part in this difference.
However, it’s also worth considering whether the expectations that society has on boys and girls, on males and females, on men and women, may be playing a part too. And some people think that it may be that society is much more accepting of externalising, or outwardly expressions of emotions, such as anger and aggression in males, whereas, for females, where that’s less acceptable, the, sort of, reactions we have to difficult emotions are more internalising. So, for example, feelings that we keep inside with anxiety and depression being an example.
So, it may be that there are biological differences, or genetic differences, or it may be that this is due to social norms and expectations. What’s important is that we are aware of anxiety disorders, and that we’re able to identify any young person who may be struggling, regardless of their gender, and we’re able to offer them the support and help they need. There is one other group that’s incredibly important when it comes to anxiety and to mental health disorders, and these are children and young people who have diverse gender roles, or who may not conform to traditional gender roles. In this group, mental health disorders, including anxiety, are unfortunately much more common, and it’s also more common to have suicidal thoughts and self-harm. And so, this is a group that we need to be particularly sensitive to, ensuring that we offer support and help as early as possible to avoid those outcomes. No matter what a child’s gender role or biological sex is, we should always be on the lookout for any signs of anxiety, or any other mental health disorders, because early identification means that we’re able to support the child or young person early, signpost them to the right places, and get them the help they need, so that they’re able to make a recovery.
Can anxiety get better? Without treatment, so this is if we do not recognise that a child is very anxious, we do not get them the help and support that they need, anxiety is likely to persist, and it can go on to affect a child’s social and family functioning, and their overall quality of life. Anxiety disorders in childhood can increase the risk of anxiety disorders in adulthood as well, and they can, also, if untreated and unmanaged, they can increase the risk of the person going on to develop depression and low mood, substance use disorders, or self-harm. Anxiety is often seen as a problem that can lead to other problems if it’s not treated, and so that’s why it’s very important to detect it and to get help for it as soon as possible.
If we look at mild anxiety, okay, this is – most children do grow out of mild anxiety. However, a few can continue being anxious and can sometimes become anxious or depressed as adults. Even if they do not become anxious or depressed as adults, anxiety can limit a young person’s activities, their attendance at school, their friendships, or their attendance at other activities, which can mean missing out on education, or missing out on making friends, and so the emotional effects of this can be long-lasting. And so, even in mild anxiety, it’s important to detect this early and get help early.
With more moderate and more severe anxiety, again, the earlier you can get help, the more likely it is to have a positive outcome. And studies have shown that up to about 68% of children who receive treatment for their anxiety, and the treatment can be therapies, or medications in some cases, so 68% of these children showed a significant improvement in their anxiety, and in at least half of them, this improvement remained for six years. So, when they were looked – when those children were investigated and asked questions six years later, half of them were still in remission, so they were not experiencing their anxiety anymore.
So, I think the important message here is that anxiety can persist and it can last, and so it is important for early help to be offered, and early support to be offered, especially when anxiety is more moderate or more severe, and that when this treatment and support is given, there is a good chance of recovery. Anxiety is not black and white, on or off, though, and with any child who is predisposed to anxiety, it’s important to always be aware that certain transition points or certain stressful points throughout life may make the anxiety come back or get worse.
So, these are things like starting a new school, moving from primary to secondary school, or a family break up, or big exams that year. So, if we know that a child we look after is known to have anxiety, or has experienced anxiety in the past, then we need to be very sensitive around those points, to ensure that we put extra support in place, and that we are especially aware and on the lookout for any signs of anxiety, so that we’re able to support them through that time.
You know, there’s a lot to say for being proactive and for taking a preventative approach, trying to prepare and plan ahead for anything that may be stressful, rather than managing the crisis after it happens. So, with anxiety, again, the most important thing is to be able to identify it, to get help early, and to manage and anticipate any future anxiety provoking events and preparing for them.