Transcript
Associate Professor Stephen Becker This article in Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry was led by Professor Edmund Sonuga-Barke, and it was a really nice opportunity to reflect back on the past 50 years of research on ADHD, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and how far we’ve come, but also, that there’s so much left that we still need to understand and learn, to help support individuals with ADHD. And so, that was really the goal of the article, to look back in time to what we’ve accomplished and what we’ve learnt, but also be very forward-looking in terms of what the next pressing questions are to address in the next stage of research.
The section that I had the opportunity to work on was specific to co-occurring conditions that very frequently are part of, or coincide with, ADHD. So, specifically the section that I thought about a lot was emotional dysregulation, which there’s been a lot of research interest in in recent decades, but then, also, sleep problems, as well as sluggish cognitive tempo, or what we’ve more recently referred to as cognitive disengagement syndrome, a set of behaviours characterised by excessive daydreaming, mental confusion or fogginess, kind of, slowed behaviour or thinking. And research that started in the 1980s related to sluggish cognitive tempo, and where that’s gone, over the last several decades, has been exciting to see [pause].
For ADHD and sleep, I think one of the established facts is simply how prevalent sleep difficulties are in individuals with ADHD. To the point that actually the diagnostic manual, the DSM-III, back in the 1980s, restless sleep was actually one of the symptoms used to define the disorder. That went away in DSM-IV in 1994, but sleep has been a longstanding part of the clinical picture for many individuals with ADHD. Whether that’s poor quality sleep, insufficient sleep, or taking a really long time to fall asleep, a long sleep onset latency, as well as growing research interest in circadian function related to ADHD, has been a long history, as well.
In terms of ADHD and sluggish cognitive tempo, for a long time there – the prevailing question really was, are sluggish cognitive tempo symptoms, again, daydreaming, mental confusion, fogginess, or that slowness or lethargy, are those really different, empirically, from ADHD inattentive symptoms? And a number of studies, over the course of a few decades, started to consistently show that, yes, they are empirically distinct. And so, then research started to turn a little bit more to, if these symptoms are different from ADHD, do they relate to functioning in different ways? In terms of, do they relate to functioning in terms of kids’ lives, in terms of their academic or social, emotional adjustment? And that’s largely where the research currently is in terms of thinking through how we measure this construct to better assess it, so that we can understand how it relates to functional outcomes in children and adults with and without ADHD [pause].
Related to ADHD and sleep, one of the new leads was a study that I had the opportunity to lead several years ago now, where we recruited adolescents, 13 to 17 years old, who all were diagnosed comprehensively by our team with ADHD. And what we did was, we did a sleep restriction extension protocol with these teens to really get at the question of does shortened sleep duration – could we see that as a causal contributor to ADHD symptoms or associated co-occurring conditions or impairments in teens with ADHD?
And so what we did is, for three weeks during the summer months – we did not want to negatively impact their actual grades or their performance during school, so we did the study during the summer months, and the teens came in for three weeks, three different visits on Friday mornings. And what we did is we randomised them to which order, that they would get either a short sleep week, where their – if they restricted their sleep to being in bed for about six and a half hours a night, or an extended sleep, where they were instructed to stay in – be in bed for nine and a half hours at night. But their wakeup time was consistent for all three weeks.
And what we found was really compelling and pretty convincing evidence that during the shortened sleep week, teens not only had more significant ADHD inattentive symptoms specifically, but also worsened mood, more depressive symptoms. They did also have higher sluggish cognitive tempo symptoms, as well as impact on their positive and negative affect. And so, that’s really a pretty important study for showing that shortened sleep duration might actually not only be part of the clinical picture with ADHD, but also be a part of the causal contributor to ADHD symptoms, or their severity in individuals with ADHD.
A study that I’ll highlight in terms of sluggish cognitive tempo, that I think is a nice recent lead, is thinking through, how does SCT symptoms predict adjustment longitudinally? The vast majority of studies in this area continue to be cross-sectional studies, which are very informative, very helpful, but certainly we need to move the field to be thinking more developmentally and then, also be looking at mechanisms and processes across development. And so, in one study, with some – my colleagues, including Dr Erik Willcutt, and Len Burns, what we were able to do is look prospectively in a large sample of youth to show actually a different – associations that sluggish cognitive tempo and ADHD inattentive symptoms had with specific academic outcomes. We found that SCT symptoms longitudinally predicted worse reading functioning in adolescents, whereas ADHD inattentive symptoms predicted poor math functioning in adolescents. So, really, we need to replicate that finding, further test that out, but that’s a – those are the sorts of differentials, and understanding why those differentials and associations might exist, I think are really novel new findings, that we’ll need to follow-up on in future research [pause].
There are so many different avenues, both related to sleep and sluggish cognitive tempo in the context of ADHD. For sleep, I really do think we need to have a much better understanding of both sleep function, but also circadian function, and that interplay of sleep and circadian function in the context of either the aetiology or the maintenance or the severity of ADHD across the lifespan, that, to me, is really a pressing question. In addition to really thinking about how do we treat sleep in the context of ADHD? Whether or not that’s through medication, whether or not that’s through supplements, such as melatonin, bright light therapy, or other cognitive behavioural based sleep interventions, I think are all really exciting directions that would, hopefully, not only inform our knowledge, but importantly, improve the lives for individuals with ADHD who also experience various sleep or circadian disruptions.
And for sluggish cognitive tempo, like I mentioned, we do need to have far more longitudinal studies, including studies with multiple timepoints, to really start testing developmental processes and mechanisms, as well as a more robust measurement in terms of thinking through the neurobiology and neurophysiology that might underly sluggish cognitive tempo in the context of ADHD.