Transcript
Professor David Daley Hello, I’m Professor David Daley from Nottingham Trent University and I’m here today to talk a little bit more about psychological interventions for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Before we talk about the essential ingredients that make up most psychological interventions for parents who wish to help their children with ADHD, I thought I would address one of the major controversies in this area, which is in the past, these interventions have been called ‘parent training programmes’. And the assumption has been that parents need to access these interventions because they have deficits in their parenting, and that’s actually not correct.
Most parents of children with ADHD parent perfectly fine, or they parent their typically developing children perfectly fine. The problem comes when they try and apply those same parenting practices to children with, or at risk of, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and there, they find that those normal parenting practices don’t work very well. And that’s why we have specialised parenting interventions to help these parents to alter their parenting style so that they can parent their children with ADHD in a way that best fits the needs of those children.
So, with that in mind, let’s take a little bit of time to think about what are some of the key ingredients of most of the different interventions for parents of children with ADHD? And most of those interventions include elements of psychoeducation. So, psychoeducation is where you provide information to the parent to help them to better understand ADHD in their child. The aim of psychoeducation is to help parents understand why their children with ADHD actually behave in the way that they do. And once those parents have a better understanding of why their children behave in the way that they do, they then have a better understanding of the strategies that are made available in the interventions, that aim to disrupt that process.
So, for example, lots of parents of children with ADHD will say that their children are very impatient, and they cannot wait a couple of minutes when they make a request. So, mum or dad may be on the phone, having an important telephone call, and the child is hungry, and the parents, quite reasonably, say, “Once I finish my call in a few minutes, I’ll make you a sandwich.” And after a couple of seconds, that child is back pestering for that sandwich. What psychoeducation would do in this situation is it would help the parents understand that ADHD children have a very poor understanding of time and that when the parent says, “Wait five minutes,” the child thinks that really is five seconds. And so, the child waits five seconds, thinking it’s five minutes, and then, wonders why the parent isn’t making a sandwich for them, and so, goes back to the parent to remind them that they’re hungry and to remind them that the parents promised to make them a sandwich.
From the parents’ point of view, the parents know what five minutes feels like. They know the child has only waited for five seconds and they think the child’s behaviour is actually really unreasonable. And so, this is an example of where psychoeducation can help parents understand why their child with ADHD behaves in the way that they do and can also help guide the parents in communicating with the child in a way that will better suit the needs of both the child and the parent.
Other key features of psychological interventions for ADHD also focus on improving parent-child relationships. Parenting a child with ADHD is actually a very difficult task and even in the preschool period, the relationship between the parent and child can become quite fraught. Relationships can deteriorate quite rapidly. Parents can feel like they’ve put a lot of effort into parenting the child, yet the child doesn’t respond to requests, doesn’t follow instructions, won’t listen to the parent. And over time, that can have a really negative impact on the relationship between parent and child, and so, most psychological interventions aim to try and foster or promote better parent-child relationships. Mostly through the form of play when children are much younger, so teaching games that help parents to rediscover the joy of spending time with their child, but also by using games to help parents better understand their child’s ability and also, to, perhaps, help teach the child some skills that they may struggle with, such as planning or working memory.
Nearly all psychological interventions for parents of children with ADHD include a focus on core behavioural strategies. So, these are standard behavioural techniques, nothing particularly new, we’ve known about them for a long time, but we use them because we know they work. And most interventions for parents of children with ADHD would have a focus both on antecedent techniques and also, consequence-based techniques. So, antecedent techniques are strategies that parents would use before a behaviour actually is exhibited. So, that might include distraction, it might include anticipation, where the parent knows the child is going to have a tantrum and would intervene early to help the child calm down.
Consequence-based strategies are behavioural strategies that the parents would implement after a behaviour has been exhibited. That might involve using rewards, it might involve using praise or even sanctions, depending on whether the behaviour that was exhibited was positive or negative. Behavioural techniques also, in most of these interventions, also focus on ways in which parents can increase the amount of reward and incentives available to children with ADHD and they particularly focus on things like reward charts. Helping parents to shape the child’s behaviour by having a much clearer focus on reward and making sure that behaviours that the child engages in are rewarded and are rewarded immediately. So, that the child makes the connection between engaging in the behaviour, it might be putting your shoes away, it might be keeping your seatbelt on in the car, and the reward that follows it.
Nearly all interventions for parents of children with ADHD also have a focus on either coaching or scaffolding. So, coaching is where we – the intervention teaches the parents how to help the child acquire some of the skills that they may be struggling with. For instance, lots of children with ADHD don’t pay attention to what’s going on in their environment and so, they don’t listen as well as children without ADHD. That means they don’t learn as well and so, interventions either teach the parent how to coach the child so that they can acquire those skills that they’re missing, or they teach scaffolding. And scaffolding is a particular technique where we, first of all, encourage parents to become observant about the child’s true level of ability.
Often, parents overestimate their ADHD child’s level of ability. A classic example of that for a young child is where the parents ask the child to get dressed. So, they may hand the child their clothes and say, “Get dressed,” and then, the parent may get very cross when the child doesn’t follow the instruction. And when we teach parents to scaffold, first of all, we encourage them to be curious about what is it that my child can and cannot do? And when parents become observant and start questioning what their child can or cannot do, they suddenly realise that their children with ADHD often struggle with things that they’re surprised by.
So, for example, perhaps the child isn’t able to do up buttons correctly. So, there’s no point handing the child their clothes to put on if they can’t do up the buttons themselves. Other children with ADHD really struggle with planning and getting dressed actually requires quite a lot of planning. Underwear, usually, unless you’re Superman, needs to go on underneath the outer clothes, so you need to plan to put on underwear first and then, put on your trousers and your T-shirt. And even that simple amount of planning can be too much for young children with ADHD, and this is where scaffolding comes in.
Scaffolding helps teach parents techniques for how they can support their children so that they can better learn. And scaffolding would involve providing the child with just the right amount of sensitive support at any one point in time so the child can complete whatever task it is that is required. So, for some children, scaffolding might just be about selecting the clothes for the child to put on. For children who find it very difficult to plan, scaffolding might involve monitoring the child’s behaviour and constantly reminding them to put their underwear on before putting on their trousers, or reminding them to turn their socks inside out before they put them on, or to make sure that the arms of their shirt are free before they put their hands into the arm.
And by teaching parents scaffolding, it helps the parents understand the child’s level of ability. It helps the parent better support the child in a much more sensitive way and so, therefore, avoiding the child getting upset or having a tantrum, and it helps extend the child’s learning. And so, scaffolding is a really key ingredient to these interventions, as it is an amazing way in which parents of children with ADHD can better support their child with ADHD and better mitogen – mitigate against some of the problems that arise for the child as a consequence of their ADHD symptoms.
In addition to some of these interventions, there are also some very ADHD specific strategies. For example, I’ve already mentioned that ADHD children find waiting very difficult because they have a very poor understanding of time, and so, some of these interventions teach ADHD specific strategies, such as how do we help children with ADHD become more resilient to waiting? A problem with waiting for children with ADHD is that ADHD children rarely wait long enough in order for waiting to have a positive outcome.
Two young children with ADHD might both have an equal desire to go on the zipwire at the local park, but because it’s a sunny day, there’s a big long queue for it. And both children will join that queue, but after a short period of waiting, the ADHD child will decide that they don’t want to go on the zipwire anymore and they’ll go off and do something else. The non-ADHD child will stay in the queue and have their go on the zipwire. So, the non-ADHD child’s waiting is rewarded. The ADHD child’s waiting is not rewarded. They waited, they gave up on waiting and so, waiting had a negative, rather than a positive, outcome.
So, some of these interventions also build in strategies that help to ensure that ADHD children have positive outcomes to waiting. The idea being that we want to move children with ADHD from being delay averse, where they always assume that waiting has a negative outcome, to being delay neutral, where sometimes waiting has a positive outcome, sometimes waiting has a negative outcome. And because it’s delay neutral, the child is much more likely to wait a little bit longer because they’re not sure what the outcome is going to be.