Transcript
Assistant Professor Jason Nagata Thanks so much for the opportunity to talk about eating disorders in boys and men for Clinicians. As an overview of today’s talk, I will start with two clinical cases, then briefly discuss the background, epidemiology, symptom presentation, assessment, treatment, medical complications, and medical guidelines for eating disorders in boys and men.
So, let’s start off with a clinical case. This is a patient who we’ll call Ashley, a 16-year-old female who described feeling fat, despite weighing less than 50kg. Her goal is to lose an additional 15kg of weight. In order to achieve this, she would skip breakfast and lunch each day, restricting to less than 500 calories per day. And if she consumed more than 500 calories per day, she would vomit or use laxatives after meals. Ashley’s case illustrates the classic disordered eating behaviours for weight loss, which include fasting or skipping meals, severe restriction of food intake, vomiting, laxatives and diuretics. These are some of the classic, typical weight loss behaviours that we associate with eating disorders.
Next, I want to turn to another case, who we’ll call Johnny, also a 16-year-old, but he is a male on the wrestling team, who was referred to our eating disorders clinic. When we asked him about all the typical behaviours for weight loss, such as fasting, restricting, vomiting or diuretics, he denied all of them. However, his parents report that he has become obsessed with his appearance, but in pursuit of achieving muscularity. He attempts to eat 3,000 calories per day of mainly protein, egg whites, whey protein powder and shakes. He’s tried to eliminate fats and carbs from his diet. In addition to wrestling practice with the team for two hours a day, he then goes to the gym to weightlift on this own for an additional three hours per day.
So, what do we call this? Is this anorexia nervosa? Does Johnny have an eating disorder? I performed a literature review on eating disorders in boys and men, and found that the vast majority of body image and eating disorder research is focused on thinness and weight loss, particularly in females, but there is – this is very understudied and under-recognised in male populations. The masculine body ideal has become increasingly large and muscular. To illustrate this point, I will cite the work of Harrison Pope at Harvard, who examined trends in muscularity of male action figures over time. Here we see Batman and Superman action figures from prior to 2000. Now, we see the Batman and Superman figurines our current children play with. Pope found that over a 30-year period, boys’ action figures have become increasingly muscular, with larger biceps, shoulders, chests and more defined abdominal and serratus muscles.
Social media is also a new phenomenon in the last decade that has contributed to pressures for boys’ body image. The limited data that we know about social media and body image, particularly in teenage boys and young men, is that boys are more likely to allow for public followings, male selfies are more likely to be full-body photos that show their muscularity, and the majority of male body image-related Instagram posts depict muscularity and leanness. Instagram use in boys and men is associated with meal skipping, disordered eating, muscle dissatisfaction, and use of anabolic steroids.
Originally, the Facebook files that were released by Frances Haugen, in terms of the Facebook whistleblower, focused on effects of Facebook and other social media platforms on teenage girls. But, recently, there’s been more recognition that these same mechanisms can affect boys and men. To achieve the idealised muscular body type, boys and men may engage in muscle-enhancing behaviours, including protein overconsumption, dietary restriction of carbohydrates and fats, appearance and performance-enhancing drugs and substances, such as anabolic steroids, androstenedione and creatine, as well as compulsive exercise. Next, I’m going to talk about the epidemiology of muscle-enhancing behaviours, and how common these are. In the United States, we surveyed adolescents and young adults in a nationally representative sample of 20,000 young people, and found that, overall, almost 30%, and actually over 30% by ages 20 to 22, of boys and young men, report that they’re trying to gain weight or build muscularity. This is much higher than the rate in girls. In order to achieve this, many boys and men, also about 30% by ages 20 to 22, are engaging in some sort of muscle building behaviour, which can include working out or excessive exercise to build muscularity, as well as supplements and drugs to promote muscularity.
Next, I’m going to talk about symptoms and presentations in males versus females in terms of eating disorders. So, some of the most commonly recognised eating disorders include anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and binge eating disorder. However, there are some special considerations that we should recognise in the presentation of males when it comes to these diagnoses. So, first of all, in anorexia nervosa, there’s a core fear of weight gain and a drive for fitness. I think it’s important to note that BMI may not be as low in males, and so there may be more in the category of atypical anorexia nervosa.
In terms of bulimia nervosa, the conceptualisation of binge eating may be that the bin – the objective binge size could be larger in males, and males may be less likely to engage in the typical purging behaviours, such as vomiting, laxatives or diuretics, but may actually present more with exercise or muscle-building supplements as a purging behaviour. And, finally, in binge eating disorder, the conceptualisation of the binge size may be larger in males, and less connected to emotional eating.
So, just as a summary, these are the diagnostic criteria for anorexia nervosa, and on the right side are some of the unique male considerations that we’ve mentioned. So, BMI may not – and weight may not be as low as males, particularly because many of them are actually not trying to lose weight, but, in fact, trying to gain muscularity. And that intense fear of gaining weight or becoming fat may not necessarily be in terms of a goal of thinness, but, in fact, a goal of leanness, as it relates to as – obscuring one’s muscularity. And then, finally, in terms of reporting shape or weight concerns, males may report shape concerns over weight concerns, particularly given that the thinness ideal is less applicable to many male populations.
In terms of bulimia nervosa, as we mentioned, the volume of food consumption during binge eating could be different and even larger for males relative to females. And it’s important to note that males may not consider what their – their binge eating behaviours as actually binge episodes, they could be termed “cheat meals” and deemed positive in the context of muscularity-oriented goals. Excessive exercise is a common compensatory behaviour in male populations, as well as appearance and performance-enhancing drugs. And we’ve already mentioned that for binge eating disorder, the volume of food consumption may be larger in males than females, and they may conceptualise this as “cheat meals.” Finally, I wanted to recognise that many of the muscularity-oriented disordered eating behaviours may not actually be captured by our traditional eating disorder diagnoses. And so, I think it’s important to realise that to assess for these behaviours, screen for them, and recognise that at excess, some of these behaviours could lead to disordered eating.
One other diagnosis that I wanted to mention is muscle dysmorphia, which is more colloquially known as bigorexia or reverse anorexia. This is technically a subtype of body dysmorphic disorder in the DSM-5, and is characterised by a preoccupation or obsession with insufficient muscularity, though in many cases an individual’s build is objectively normal, or even muscular. Muscle dysmorphia is more common in males than females, and may present with engagement in muscle-enhancing behaviours.
I wanted to briefly overview some assessment tools that could be used for boys and men in terms of eating disorders, muscle dysmorphia and related symptomatology. One thing to note is that many of the measures that were developed for eating disorders were originally designed for female samples. And so, some options are to modify existing measures to be more appropriate for males, using traditional measures, but being aware of potential bias or incompleteness, and then using some of the few measures that have been developed specifically and validated for both males and females, and using some in combination.
So, in terms of assessing eating disorder symptoms, the – perhaps one of the most commonly using – used measures is the Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire. I also wanted to note that the Muscularity Oriented Eating Test was designed specifically to measure muscularity-oriented eating concerns, which may not be captured in the Eating Disorder Examination. In terms of body image related measures that are applicable to males, there is a Male Body Attitudes Scale, as well as a Drive for Muscularity Scale, which can capture some of those unique phenomenon in males. Then, finally, in terms of assessing muscle dysmorphia, two measures that have been designed to assess this is – are the Muscle Dysmorphic Disorder Inventory and the Muscle Dysmorphia Inventory.
Next, wanted to talk about some treatment considerations for males. Overall, we know that males are less likely to seek treatment. There is a double stigma for males with eating disorders. There is already the stigma for eating disorders, in general, and then there’s a second stigma because eating disorders are a feminised disease, and recognition may not be as apparent in male populations. I think it’s important to note that there actually aren’t specific treatments or controlled trials that have been tested in male populations, and oftentimes, in the larger trials, sex differences in outcomes are not usually examined. However, treatment response for males tends to be similar than in females.
Some considerations to factor in include addressing concerns about muscular – masculinity and muscularity. So, there may be shame about symptoms and reluctance to focus on emotions. And, in the group setting, I think it’s also important to understand the group dynamics. And so, in some situations, a male patient with an eating disorder may be the only person in the group who is male-identifying, and so that’s one consideration, particularly if the group is mostly female. And, also, if possible, consider having a male and female Clinician to co-lead the group. Next, wanted to talk about acute medical complications of eating disorders in male populations. Overall, eating disorders can cause significant medical complications, affecting every organ system in the body. But there’s limited and growing research that has examined medical complications of eating disorders in boys and men.
Overall, the limited data does show that eating disorders in boys and men can affect your heart or cardiac system, including a lower heartrate, lower blood pressure, and orthostatic vital signs, and neurologic changes, including structural brain changes, haematologic or blood changes such as anaemia, low platelets and low white blood cell count, including no – neutropenia, gastrointestinal and liver complications, including slow gastric emptying and elevated liver enzymes, which in extreme cases, can lead to liver failure. Electrolyte abnormalities such as hypokalaemia, hypophosphatemia, or hypomagnesemia, as well as considerations for refeeding syndrome, are also present in male populations.
In terms of endocrine complications, the growth suppression can occur and abnormalities in thyroid regulation, as well as lower testosterone and libido can also take effect. And, finally, in terms of skeletal complications, we have noted higher risks of fracture in males with eating disorders, as well as lower bone density. This is all extremely important because, unfortunately, in male populations, there is an elevated mortality, so 13% of males with anorexia nervosa, unfortunately, will die from it, as well as 11% of those with bulimia nervosa. And standardised mortality rates in males with anorexia nervosa are six to eight times higher than the male reference population.
I wanted to note that traditionally, eating disorder guidelines have been focused on female samples, but in the last few years, there have been more specific guidance for males and boys and men. And so, I just wanted to mention that recently, the Society for Adolescent Health and Medicine has updated their guidelines to be more inclusive of boys and men. We worked on this book, which is a clinical reference for Clinicians taking care of boys and men with eating disorders. And this is the 2022 Society for Adolescent Health and Medicine guidance that includes, for the first time, a position and statement on eating disorders in boys and men, particularly for their medical considerations.
Overall, I wanted to thank a large number of collaborators who have helped with the research and guideline development, particularly for this slide presentation, as well as a number of students and trainees in my lab group, and a number of funders who have supported this research. Thank you so much for your time.