Transcript
Dr Porpavai Kasiannan And we will briefly look at the infant brain development, which is the biological, sort of, side of things. I'm not going to go into great details of this, but just touch upon some of the salient factors in infant brain development. So, the human brain development is interesting in its – in the way it is – it's – it has evolved. The brain develops from bottom up and from inside out. So, the lower building blocks are constituted by the brain stem and the midbrain, which are the – called – generally called the “survival brain,” and the upper building blocks are the intellectual brain, which is the cortex, and limbic system, sort of, is the inside brain, which kind of regulates our emotions, our memory and some of those, kind of, functions.
So, if we look at human brain development, synaptic formation is always dependent on experiences. So, when babies experience a certain sensory experience, such as, visual or hearing or touch, those synapses are formed based on those experiences. And if we look at the development, the sensory pathways, such as vision and hearing, develop in the first few months of infancy and language develops through – towards the third, fourth quarter. Starts to develop in infancy, in terms of babbling, but then develops further, during the last, sort of, quarter of the first year of life and continues to develop further. And higher cognitive functions, particularly the frontal cerebral cortex, develops – continues to develop, or continues to form connections, until - to the mid-20s.
So, brain development, the – one concept to understand in brain development is neuroplasticity, and in infants, there are two different neuroplasticity concepts that are important to know. One is the experience "expectant plasticity," which requires specific types of input, for example, light input into the retina in the first months of life for normal visual development is important. And another one is also crucially, some language input for language development, although it is very rare to see infants not developing speech because of lack of hearing sounds and – but there are historical accounts of, you know, "wolf boy" and, you know, children who have been found with lack of human input for the first few years of life, and they don't have any speech. And it's very difficult for them to learn to speak aft – if they haven't had that initial, sort of, input in the first few years of life.
The second type of plasticity is the "experience dependent plasticity," which is not constrained to specific developmental periods. It can develop at anytime during the child development, such as, learning music or sports, or, you know, activities such as that. But having said that, the ex – the skills can develop much more robustly if they are started earlier in life rather than later in life. So, it might take longer to learn music and things if the kids start learning later in life.
So, brain development starts in utero and continues until the mid-20s, like I mentioned. In the first nine months, the baby's brain is forming connections between what they see, hear, taste and feel, and from about nine to 12 months, the baby will become increasingly vocal as their understanding of emotions develop. By the age of three, the child has around 1,000 trillion brain connections or synapses, the most they will ever have in their life, because as they grow older, these get pruned in later development.
And what is the parent’s role in brain development? You know, parents play a key role in the development of their child's brain before and after birth. They contribute genes that, to a smaller or larger extent, determines their infant’s temperament and behaviour, and after birth, parents are still influencing their child's brain through environment they provide, and also by their interactions, particularly by a concept called “serve and return,” like in tennis. So, in this interaction there is a mutual serve and return between the child, or the infant, and the parent. So, the infant coos or makes a sound, and the parent returns the serve by making a similar sound, making eye contact, or associated with cuddles or, you know, smiles. And the baby returns the serve from the parent, and the parent returns the serve, so on and so forth. This kind of serve and return actually increases the synaptic connections within the brain and improves the development of skills within the infant.
And animal studies have shown that significant maternal stress during pregnancy and poor maternal care during infancy, they both affect the developing stress system in young animals, and they can even alter genes that are involved in the brain development. And in human infants, toxic stress, which is stress that cannot be tolerated, you know, can potentially affect the brain architecture. So, the toxic stress in infants would be where there is severe neglect, where there is severe family violence or domestic violence, physical abuse, and so on and so forth, and this can potentially affect the brain architecture and future development of emotional and behavioural issues.
Okay, we have looked at the theories of development, the brain development, and now we will move onto what are the developing domains in the in – in infancy that influence parenting? So, when we look at the domains of infant development, the – we know that – we've just looked at how there is growing complexity of the nervous system and the children grow. There is alterations in the shape and capacity of the infant’s body, there is sharpening of sensory and perceptual capacities, and there is increases in abilities to make sense of, understand and master objects in the world. And babies gradually, you know, learn communication skills, and emergence of characteristic personal and social styles, individual personality starts developing in – during infancy. And they also form specific bonds, or attachment patterns, with their caregivers.
One of the domains is state, so state in which the infant is in. Infants vary in how soon they establish a predictable schedule of behavioural states, for example, you know, whether they are in a calm state or in an agitated state or upset state, and how their regularity is, or lack of regularity. Do they have a good sleep-wake pattern or good feeding pattern in terms of schedules? All these have critical implications for infant care, and, also, you know, the wellbeing of the parents. Because the lesser the regularity, it's very difficult for parents to look after infants.
It is estimated that mothers lose an average of 350 hours of sleep during their infant’s first year, mainly because of the multiple awakenings of their infant and that mothers experience negative effects of the sleep deprivation, without even being fully aware that they are sleep deprived. And, also, infants who are temperamentally fretful, they elicit different patterns of interactions than do infants who cry only infrequently. So, it is quite understandable, you know, children who are more irritable, they do elicit, you know, a fearful response from the parents, or a frustrated response from the parents. And, also, the amount of time infants spend in different states determines how they are with the parents. For example, usually babies are usually with the mothers when they are awake and they're alone when sleep in the Western, sort of, situation, but in many Eastern and Southeastern – Southeast Asian countries the babies are with the parents all the time because they co-sleep with the parents.
And cultural determinants also, sort of, impact on how the infant’s state influence the parenting, for example, in the Kipsigis tribe of Kenya, the infants are always carried around on the back of their mothers while they go about their day-to-day work, and the infants sleep next to their mother and feed whenever, you know, they need or want. So, they don't actually have a regular cycle of, you know, sleeping through the night and, you know, awake during the day. They fall asleep when they are being carried around, they have naps during the day, and they might have interrupted sleep during the night. When compared to the American baby or an Australian baby, they would, you know, be expected to have this, you know, sleep-wake cycle sorted out by the end of the first year, or even by the end of the first few months of life.
And there's – the second domain is the "physical stature and psychomotor ability" influences how parents in – parent their infants. So, in the first year, babies grow half their birth length and their weight triples, you know, from the birth weight. There's significant advances in motor skills. By walking, infants establish independence, capacity for exploration, maturity and self-mindedness. And again, parental cultural expectations play a major role in infant development. For example, some cultures expect the infants to sit and move sooner than other cultures where they get carried around for quite a bit and they don't start moving independently until a little later.
The other domain that infants develop is perceiving and thinking, you know. Although infants are infants, they have an active mental life. They are constantly learning and developing, and newborns are, as we said, are equipped to hear, orient to and to distinguish sound, and are especially primed to perceive and to appreciate sound in the dynamic form and range of adult speech. So, that's very evident that adults also modulate their speech in a way to suit the infants. Somehow, intuitively they do that. And newborns can identify particular voices, especially mothers, and evidence suggests that newborns have developed a good sense of smell, as well. Infants discriminate among facial expressions associated with different emotions by about four to five months of age, and they can even distinguish variations in some emotional expressions. And they have gaze, I mean, develop gaze and eye-to-eye contact very early on in the development.
Infants can imitate too. You know, they can poke their tongues out, when tongue – you know, when adults poke tongue, but there is a little bit of – more than a little bit of debate about what infants can imitate and how early they can imitate. As a huge amount of – some schools saying that they can imitate from very young onwards, whereas others don't agree with it. So, the verdict's still out there. However, there is no debate that observational learning starts from infancy. Whether they imitate or not, they – early or not, they still learn by observation, and as we have discussed before, infancy culminates with the development of representational thinking and language. Another development that happens is play. So, when the infants are younger, it's generally sensorimotor manipulation of mouthing toys or shaking rattles or, you know, those kind of activities. To symbolic play by the second year, where they're picking up an object and pretending to be talking on the phone, or swiping, as they do see adults doing on their phones, etc.
Then comes the language development and understanding of communications. So, when infants are younger, their com – their only way of communication is by crying, when they’re newborn. And so smiling happens, you know, very soon, and then slowly, they organise speech sounds by babbling. The repertoire of communication increases to include gestures, you know, with pointing, showing and growing range of other social signals. The motivation to learn language or acquire language is a social phenomena, and is bor – very much tied to the interaction with others, particularly the parents in the environment.
Another important milestone of development is joint attention. So, joint attention is a behaviour where two people share a focus on an object or event. This interaction is crucial for better social engagement and communication. So, the infants are usually able to pr – you know, you know, do joint attention activities by about seven, eight, nine months of age, and if that is not developing, it is usually a red flag for possibly underlying neurodevelopmental disorder, such as autism. In the space of approximately two years, infants master the basics of language, espec – in the context of infant-adult social communication, and this happens without explicit instruction, teaching, without any effort, but they always speak the language to which they have been exposed.
Babies are also able to express their emotions, and they also – we talked about “temperament” early on. This is usually supported by the mothers and caregivers earlier on in life. By the middle of the first year, second-half of first year, parents’ emotional expressions become meaningful to infants, so they can look at the parents and they will smile or frown or cry, depending upon what they interpret from the parent’s emotional expression. And they respond emotionally to affective expressions they observe in other people, and they can show signs of distress when they are witnessing angry interactions. And this has been quite widely studied in the context of family violence and trauma. And temperamental differences in – also influences how parents respond to infants.
We saw in the goodness-of-fit that, you know, certain temperaments can elicit a negative response from parents, whereas certain temperaments don't. And if the parents are able to be flexible and match their responsiveness to the child's temperament, there is less distress and conflict in the relationship. Again, cultural variation shapes the interaction between infant emotional expression or temperament and parenting, because some cultures, by nature, encourage emotional expression right from very young age onwards, whereas some cultures do not. And so, those things will develop a little bit differently compared to the cultures which encourage emotional expressions.
Infants also have a wide-ranging and interesting social life, right from birth onwards. By about two months of age, they're already engaging in complex and responsive interactions with the mothers. These are called “protoconversations,” and this is quite evid – you know, when you talk to mothers, they can see how they have exchange with their infants. Which, you know – whether it is through – you know, by mutual, sort of, give and take exchanges in the form of cooing, gazing, smiles, grunts and so on. And infants also develop a sense of shared experience, termed “intersubjectivity,” coin – a term coined by Trevarthen.
The development of emotional relationships with other people, mainly parents, constitutes one of the most important aspects of social developments in infancy, and as some - study by Ainsworth and Bowlby. So, this, the – espec – particularly in the attachment relationships, and they’re, kind of, also, sort of, the foundation for aspects of social development. Infant-mother interactions have also been referred to as the “cradle of social understanding,” for how they presumably colour later social relationships.
Another aspect of infancy that influences or impacts parenting is the change in development that happens in infancy. It is a – infancy is a phase of dynamic change. There is always something that is changing, you know, day-to-day, if not, you know, hour-to-hour kind of changes. So, there is a parallel and rapid growth in biological, psychological and social skills. It's generally not a linear kind of development, it is non-linear in nature, it could be, like, a stepwise progression. There could be stalling in the development sometimes, and sometimes they can have temporary regressions in the development, depending on the context.
As infant matures and is exposed to new experiences, changes can happen in many levels at the same time. Even though the dynamic change is rapid and non-linear, there can be individual variations in infants. For example, some infants start to walk early, compared to others, who – you know, by nine months or ten months, and whereas other infants might walk only by 15 months. And some infants have, you know, 30 words by the end of, you know, 13/14 months and some infants may just have only a few words, and even comprehension of words, again, could be different. All these things are – doesn't mean that there is a developmental delay, but there is an individual variation in the development.
So, for parents, it means that it's almost they're trying to deal with a moving target. You know, one day the infant is crawling, and the next day they are walking. And so they have to start, sort of, looking at keeping things safe from the infant’s reach so that they don't get hurt. Parents are constantly trying to, sort of, figure out what's going on in the baby's head so they can prepare themselves and the baby for the next stage of development. And the biology and the culture that parents come from equip the parents to respond, understand and interpret infancy and its vicissitudes, because I think this is something that, you know, that is not overtly obvious, but parents have, sort of, innate, kind of, instincts and things - and the things that they have learned from their own culture that they use in their parenting.