Transcript
Jasmine Snowdon Hello, and thank you for watching my presentation today. This will be on the importance of mental health nursing in child and adolescent mental health services. My name’s Jasmine Snowdon. I’m a Registered Adult and Mental Health Nurse, and a Senior Teaching Fellow in the Mental Health Nursing Teaching Team, at the University of Southampton. I also look after the dual field programmes at Southampton, so that’s adult mental health and child mental health programmes.
Okay, so a little bit about me is that I trained as an Adult and Mental Health Nurse a while ago, and that really inspired me to move into eating disorders, because I felt I could use my physical health nursing skills and my mental health nursing skills. What I noticed while I was there was that there was quite a lot of older people, or people that were in, kind of, middle ages of 20 to 50, that had had repeat admissions into the inpatient eating disorders unit, that hadn’t received the support, and the family support, that they could have had when they were younger.
So, after seeing this, and becoming quite attached to the people that I was working with, and wish I could have helped them at a younger age, I moved into child and adolescent mental health services. So, first off, I worked in an inpatient service, which was a mix of eating disorders and general psychiatric. So what means is all your other psychiatric conditions, such as depression, anxiety, that were more severe, and psychosis was more the predominant one that we saw and, also, sometimes emotional dysregulation and trauma, where people were a risk to themselves.
And then, from that experience, I really wanted to help people in the community, ‘cause I felt it was better for young people to be in the community, and to work with their families more closely, and be in that role of an educator to prevent hospital admission. Hospital admission can be really traumatising for young people, and they can build a sense of community within the inpatient service, but, also, from my clinical experience, it was not necessarily helpful for them to be out of school, away from their family for long periods of time. So, I wanted to be that Community Practitioner that would help young people in the community.
So, move now. And then I was interested in educating Student Nurses, ‘cause what I noticed is that a lot of my colleagues became more anxious around managing risk, which at times, sometimes, made their practices restrictive, and we know this from the literature, that restrictive practice can be quite common. So, what I want to do is install that level of confidence and ability to adapt in the care that they were delivering, by teaching Student Nurses through case scenarios, and my own clinical experience, on how to manage a person safely in the community, by also seeking to help – some help from your team members, and knowing when admission is needed, because it’s not always avoidable. But it’s what you do in terms of discharge planning and how to support that young person so that admission is useful, rather than prolonged over a period of time when they don’t need to be there for different reasons. So, for example, we few – we saw a few people for social care reasons.
And then I was interested in research into the impact of skill mix in child and adolescent mental health services, and that’s what I’ll be talking in part about in this session. Okay, so just to give some background, there’s different fields of nursing within the UK, so I know this is an international platform. So mental health nursing in the UK is a profession grounded in empathy, advocacy and empowerment, and it’s walking alongside the individual in their journey with their mental health and working with their fluctuating mental health.
It’s also about working with the person in promoting recovery focused models and reducing stigma, and help the individual build and to adapt with different life situations they may encounter. We also do integrated – integrating therapeutic relationships, and fulfilling lives, so that helps us have a greater understanding of reducing restrictive practices, ‘cause we want to keep people in the community, and we want us all to be working together collaboratively, in the hope that they can begin to make some positive changes in their life.
So, child and adolescent mental health nursing, in particular, we work in a restorative way with the family. So it’s not about if the parent has maybe, for example, hurt the child in some way, or has maybe not been the best parent on paper, we want to work with them, to help keep that child in the family, within safe restrictions. So, we work very safely and effectively with social care services, and we make sure that they’re always involved in the meetings that we’re having, to make sure the child at the centre of the care is safe, but, ultimately, we want to be able to work with the family as a whole. And Mental Health Nurses play a really critical role in that, because we sit within the biopsychosocial model.
So, in child and adolescent mental health services, we use more of a psychosocial model, because where they’re less physically unwell, and that’s de – different in eating disorders, but we try to work with the family collaboratively, using those psychosocial interventions. So, what we might do is educate the parent on how to manage risk, how to communicate with the young person, and seeing the young person as their own person, and, also, working within the i-THRIVE model. So making sure that the young person’s thriving and gets help when they need it.
So, under the Nursing and Midwifery Council, there’s four fields mental health, child, adult, and learning disabilities. Okay, so, what made me passionate about looking at research in this area was that from my clinical experience, I noticed there was a significant gap in-between the literature from my adult nursing counterpart in my other registration and my mental health registration. So, it meant that I was noting a lot of restrictive practices while I was in a clinical setting, and it means that young people were sometimes kept in hospital when they weren’t necessarily mentally unwell at the time, but they were struggling to get housing, which then had a significant impact on their mood.
Also, the staffing ratio, sometimes they’re understaffed, but there was also a lack of insight into the importance of the role of the Mental Health Nurse, because sometimes the work that we’re doing – and it’s hard to quantify what mental health nursing is. So there is an element of sitting down with people and having a cup of tea, but there’s also the elements there that we have a greater understanding of the law, how to manage risk, and those therapeutic interventions, and how to apply them on a lighter or heavier level.
There was quite a divide between psychology and mental health nursing, in terms of the young person might go and see the Psychologist, and then we wouldn’t necessarily get the best handover, and then they’d be onto the ward, and potentially have an incident, ‘cause we had that breakdown in communication around what the young person had just spoken about and why they were upset. It’s also how incidences were managed, so we’d have a lot of people on the ward, but not necessarily a lot of people engaging the young people in activities. And that was partly to do with the skill mix of people knowing what they needed to do, but that’s just from my personal experience. So that’s what made me passionate about it originally, so not everywhere will be like that, but that was my experience of inpatient care.
I also noticed that people were – had delayed discharges, so it meant that they could be in the community, but they had been in inpatient for so long that they felt like that was their home, rather than the home they were going to go to. So, they’d built up a network, they had regular meals, there was people caring for them, in a safe and warm environment, and sometimes that’s not the environment they’re living in before being admitted into hospital. This is what we don’t know about skill mix in inpatient care. So, as you can see, there’s a significant gap in the literature since COVID-19. So a lot of what I’ve looked at in researching this was that the literature hasn’t been updated. So there was a significant increase in admissions of children and young people, and especially children and young people that had a diagnosis of autism as well as a mental illness. So, those were the people that were more likely to be admitted, but there was very limited literature on what’s going on for them and what’s changed since 2019.
There’s an overall lack of research globally around quality and safety in mental health care, so I was hoping to build on that. There’s a lack of understanding of difference between the care of adults with mental illness and the care of children and young people with mental illness, and why those important – differences are so important. ‘Cause there’s completely different legal frameworks that you’re working under, children have less ability to make decisions, but still need to be involved in decision-making and understand, to the maximum of their age range, what is happening at what times, and they need to be involved in their care.
Adults have more autonomy, overall, but, also, in terms of how we work with children, there is more resource. So it means that the wards do tend to be better staffed and the community teams are better staffed, but that’s because of the volume and the amount of care that we’re able to provide, and there’s more laws in place to protect children than there is with adults. So, if an adult doesn’t consent to care, then they’re able to refuse the service, if they have capacity. Whereas, a child, you would – sometimes, they don’t understand what they’re declining, or what the treatment is, so we’ll work with them for a bit longer to build up that rapport, which is so important. So, those differences aren’t necessarily understood.
And the need to involve in the – or the existing workforce for appropriate measures for quality, so we need to work with service providers, in our current workforce, to be able to do that. We have done a questionnaire that looks at workforce wellbeing and, hopefully, that will feed into that, but we don’t have anything concrete yet. There’s a lack of understanding of how the service user feels while they’re in an inpatient setting in CAMHS, so we don’t have their experience and their side of things of what they felt at the time.
There’s a lack of understanding of the links within incident data, so we collect it and we see trends to react to them immediately. So, when we’re looking at it from a Trust perspective, we will look at trends in terms of how many types of incidents are happening at one time and if there’s a type of incidents happening at one place, quite often that will be looked at, but it’s not all linked together, in terms of what was the skill mix on that day? Has any intervention been helpful? Did that young person get their one-to-one support that day that they’re supposed to have? And all of this isn’t taken into account in the current way we collect incidences, and there’s limited quality monitoring of incident data, as a whole.
So, there’s a significant gap. So the National Quality Board looked into this and said it was a research need, that we urgently need a commissioned programme for this empirical research in mental health multidisciplinary settings. Particularly in linking staffing requirements and outcomes for people with mental illnesses, and it’s a priority area that currently there is – so, there’s guidance, but there’s no plans to implement this or evaluate this currently, from the literature that I’ve looked at.
So, the idea that’s in place is, “How do different nursing services delivery models, including skills mix, specialise and interventions offered, affect the experience and outcomes of patients with mental illness based on the incident data and staffing experience?” So, this is the question that we are looking at in the United Kingdom, and my particular question will be focusing around child and adolescent mental health services and that staff and skill mix that we have here. Because there’s a lot of unknowns, and what we might see from the incident data is the more staff that you have on shift, the more incidents you have. But that’s because you might plan for that incident in that day, and without a Mental Health Nurse doing that research in child and adolescent mental health services, it’s very easy to misinterpret the data.
So, that’s where mental health nursing is so important in CAMHS, where we sit within the biopsychosocial model, so can take the psychosocial part, so work with families. But we can also do the research and add the context to it, from our clinical experience, rather than looking at the numbers and not understanding the context of those. So, thank you for listening to me today, and I hope you enjoyed this talk.